How Often You Should Replace a Coffee Maker

Coffee 101: When Should You Replace a Coffee Maker?

A quality coffee maker can last 5 years or even 10 years old depending on the daily usage and the ability of the owner to clean each of the parts. Grounds can stain a coffee maker and so the material of the maker is very important.

A good coffee maker will adjust brew strength & temperature to make the perfect cup. Our Top Coffee Maker review gives you five reliable brands and designs. Find the right Coffee Maker that fits your needs and budget with our list below.

Over the years, we’ve tried nearly every method of making coffee from drip coffee makers, French Press, to Moka Pots, and Moccamasters. So, hopefully our list will be helpful.

Best Overall Coffee Maker went to the Breville Precision Brewer. $330 at Amazon ; The Best Value Coffee Maker went to BLACK+DECKER 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker.

When should you replace a coffee maker?

You should replace a coffee maker when the coffee is no longer cleanable on the insides of the machine. This can cause trouble.

Cuisinart Coffee Maker Programmable Drip 12 cup

BREW STRENGTH CONTROL: Select regular or bold coffee flavor to perfectly match your coffee taste preference

FULLY AUTOMATIC COFFEE BREWER: 24-hour programmability with 1–4 cup settings, auto-off functionality—0-4 hours—and optional ready alert tone

12-CUP THERMAL CARAFE: Includes decorative stainless-steel handle with matching stainless-steel body to perfectly pair with your kitchen appliances

FILL WITH EASE: Easy-to-view water window for accurate filling and Cuisinart’s trademarked Brew Pause feature lets you enjoy a cup of coffee before the brewing cycle has finished

Moccamaster KBGV S

The selector switch on the KBGV Select allows you to choose between brewing a half or full carafe. The brewing speed and hotplate temperature adjust according to your choice, brewing either amount to the golden cup standard. The brew basket automatically stops the flow of coffee when removing the carafe. All glass carafe brewers feature a hotplate with an independent heating element that holds your coffee at the perfect temperature.

Moccamaster KBGV S

Best Overall Coffee Maker: Breville ® Grind Control 12 Cup Coffee Maker

The first household coffee maker to offer an adjustable grinder and calibration function, this coffee maker from Breville not only allows you to grind before you brew, you can also customize the grind size and coffee volume to suit your taste. Six settings eliminate guessing, providing the optimal grind for brewing. The built-in grinder allows you to capture coffee’s essential oils before they dissipate, using stainless steel burrs to deliver a consistent grind for a more balanced, full flavored cup.

Best Overall Coffee Maker: Breville ® Grind Control 12 Cup Coffee Maker

Cuisinart Burr Grind & Brew 12 Cup Coffee Maker

Fresh, aromatic coffee just couldn’t be simpler. This fully automatic coffee maker with timer automatically grinds the correct amount of coffee, dispenses the grounds into the filter basket and brews up to 12 cups of delicious hot coffee. This state-of-the-art features a built-in burr grinder and flavor strength options from regular to extra bold. Grind feature may be deactivated to brew with pre-ground coffee